Home › Guides › FD vs RD vs SIP
FD vs RD vs SIP
₹3 lakh over 5 years: kept in one FD at 6.5% it becomes about ₹4,14,126; put in as ₹5,000 a month in a post office RD at 6.7% it becomes about ₹3,56,829; and ₹5,000 a month in an equity SIP could be about ₹4,12,432 at 12% — or ₹3,69,834 at 8%, and less in a bad stretch.
The verdict
Choose by time, not by the highest number. For money needed within about five years, FD or RD — FD if you have the sum today, RD if you save from income. For goals seven years or more away, an equity SIP has historically done better after tax, but only because you accept years when it falls.
Side by side
| FD | RD | SIP | |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹3 lakh over 5 years | ₹4,14,126 (one deposit) | ₹3,56,829 (₹5,000/month) | ₹4,12,432 at 12% · ₹3,69,834 at 8% |
| How you invest | One lump sum | A fixed amount every month | A fixed amount every month into a mutual fund |
| Return | Fixed at booking — 6.5% assumed here, varies by bank | Fixed — 6.7% at the post office (5 years) | Market-linked — can be negative over short periods |
| Safety | Bank deposits insured up to ₹5 lakh per bank | Post office: government-backed; bank RD insured like an FD | No guarantee |
| Tax | Interest taxed at your slab every year | Interest taxed at your slab | Equity gains after 1 year: 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year; within 1 year: 20% |
| Best for | Money you already have, goals up to ~5 years | Building a saving habit for a 1–5 year goal | Goals 7 or more years away |
Figures are computed at build time by the same engines that run our calculators, and re-render when a rate changes. Returns for market-linked options (NPS, SIP) are assumptions, not promises. PPF runs beyond 15 years in 5-year extensions. Not investment advice.
Compute it yourself
Frequently asked questions
Which is better — FD, RD or SIP?
It depends on when you need the money. FD and RD give a fixed, known amount and suit goals up to about five years. A SIP can grow more over seven years or longer but carries market risk and no guarantee.
Is SIP safer than FD?
No. An FD pays a fixed rate, and bank deposits are insured up to ₹5 lakh per bank. A SIP buys mutual fund units whose value moves with the market, so it can be worth less than you invested, especially in the first few years.
Which is better for 1 year — RD or SIP?
For one year, usually an RD or FD. Equity can fall in any single year, and a one-year goal leaves no time to recover.
Last verified: 17 October 2026 — Rates from our rates file (finance-ministry quarterly notification for PPF, NSC, KVP and post office RD; EPFO for EPF; an assumed bank FD rate); rules from the Income-tax Act 2025, the EPF Scheme and PFRDA’s December 2025 exit regulations. NPS and SIP returns are assumptions · Not investment advice.