Home › Guides › PPF vs NSC vs SCSS vs FD
PPF vs NSC vs SCSS vs FD vs MIS — the honest comparison
Five government-backed or bank-guaranteed options, one table, and the same ₹5 lakh run through each at today’s rates. The tax column decides more than the rate column.
| Option | Rate | Compounding | Lock-in | Tax on interest | 80C | TDS | Who / limit | ₹5 lakh after 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PPF | 7.1% | yearly | 15 years (partial from year 7) | Interest and maturity tax-free (EEE) | Yes (old regime) | None | Any resident; ₹1.5 lakh/yr max | ₹6,17,134 on ₹5 lakh deposited over 5 yrs |
| NSC | 7.7% | yearly, paid at maturity | 5 years | Interest taxable yearly on accrual | Yes — deposit + years 1–4 interest (old) | None | Any resident; no max | ₹7,24,517 |
| SCSS | 8.2% | quarterly payout, no compounding | 5 years (+3) | Interest taxable | Yes on deposit (old) | Above ₹1 lakh/yr interest | 60+ (55 VRS, 50 defence); ₹30 lakh max | ₹7,05,000 (₹10,250/quarter paid out) |
| Bank FD (5-yr) | 6.5% assumed (varies by bank) | quarterly | as chosen; penalty on early exit | Interest taxable | Only 5-yr tax-saver FD (old) | Above ₹50,000/yr (₹1 lakh 60+) | Anyone | ₹6,90,210 |
| Post Office MIS | 7.4% | monthly payout | 5 years | Interest taxable | No | None (report yourself) | Anyone; ₹9 lakh single / ₹15 lakh joint | ₹6,85,000 (₹3,083/month paid out) |
PPF row: ₹1 lakh a year for 5 years (₹5 lakh total) because the annual cap is ₹1.5 lakh; all others: ₹5 lakh lumpsum. Figures computed from the current data file at build time.
How to read it
- After tax, PPF wins for anyone in the 20–30% slab — 7.1% tax-free equals roughly 10.1% pre-tax at 30%; NSC’s 7.7% becomes about 5.4% after 30% tax.
- SCSS is the best guaranteed income for 60+ — 8.2% paid quarterly on up to ₹30 lakh (₹60 lakh for a couple); watch the ₹1 lakh TDS line and file 15H if eligible.
- NSC beats a 5-year FD on rate and on 80C — but only in the old regime; in the new regime both are plain taxable instruments and the FD is more liquid.
- MIS is for monthly cash, not growth — pair it with a 5-year RD to compound the payouts.
- None of these beat inflation by much — for horizons beyond 7 years, see the SIP calculator for the equity comparison and its 12.5% LTCG.
Calculators
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, PPF or NSC?
PPF for tax: its 7.1% is fully tax-free, worth about 10% pre-tax in the 30% slab, but locked 15 years. NSC pays 7.7% for 5 years but the interest is taxable every year — better only for low-tax or new-regime investors who want the shorter lock-in.
Is SCSS better than a bank FD for senior citizens?
Yes on rate (8.2% vs roughly 7–7.5%), with quarterly payouts and 80C on the deposit; the cap is ₹30 lakh per person and interest above ₹1 lakh a year attracts TDS unless Form 15H is filed.
Which of these is tax-free?
Only PPF (and Sukanya Samriddhi for a daughter). NSC, SCSS, FD and MIS interest are all taxable at slab; PPF and NSC deposits and SCSS deposits qualify for 80C in the old regime.
Last verified: 17 October 2026 — Rates per MoF announcement for October–December 2026 and EPFO/bank averages; tax treatment per the Income-tax Act 2025 (s.123, s.153, s.393); projections recomputed from data/rates.json on every build · Not investment advice.